Why Man Creates
In the year of
Kubrick’s 2001: A Space Odyssey,
it attains the prey in prehistory.
From
that day to this, a dilemma. Circumstances, obstacles. The nature of
such labors, such laborers.
Academy
Award.
Phase IV
The main elements
are Haskin’s The Naked Jungle
and Wise’s The
Andromeda Strain, certain details recall Juran’s First Men in the Moon (and Kubrick’s 2001: A Space Odyssey), Kaufman probably recalls it for his version
of Siegel’s Invasion of the Body
Snatchers, the flea circus filming perhaps suggests Riesner’s
Bill and Coo (which brings you to
Hitchcock’s The Birds).
The several
phases evoke the sections of Why Man
Creates with its terrific number on the critics. “I came down here to
get in a couple o’ weeks o’ science in the sun,
I did not sign up for a war against a bunch o’ goddamn ants!”
Critics who were
mystified by the ending certainly didn’t know their Haskin from Teshigahara’s hole in the
ground, Woman in the Dunes (where the
protagonist of a surety is an entomologist).
A.H.
Weiler of the New
York Times, “beclouded by enigmas.” Variety, “didn’t get the bugs worked out before release.” Jonathan Rosenbaum (Monthly Film Bulletin), “an impossibly outworn string of
clichés and platitudes.” Jonathan Rosenbaum (Chicago Reader), “so-so”. Time Out, “still got a lot of bugs to iron out.” Halliwell’s
Film Guide, “oddly effective”.
The great selah at the finish
was eliminated by the studio or the distributor,
reports disagree, because the critical brain trust has no monopoly.